▲ Դեպի վեր

lang.iso lang.iso lang.iso


Syrian Parliament recognizes Armenian Genocide

Macron congratulates Turkish historian for “denouncing Armenian Genocide denial”

Vartine Ohanian Becomes First Female Armenian Minister in Lebanon’s History

Azerbaijani singer refuses to share stage with Armenian opera singer at Dresden Opera Ball

The US Embassy in Armenia donated firefighting equipment to the Ministry of Emergency Situations

Nikol Pashinyan welcomes Presidents of Iran and US from the peak of Artanish (2461m)

Information that Pashinyan has congratulated the Tramp on the military operation in Baghdad is FAKE

Cool music, a lot of new cocktails, and tangerine. New Year in Jean Paul

Պետական ​​կրթաթոշակ ՝ Սիլիկոնյան հովտում սովորելու համար

SAS Group’s holiday surprise for Orran children

Senator Menendez cried out in thanksgiving for the Genocide Resolution

US Senate recognizes the Armenian Genocide

Weightlifting Championship in Israel. Armenian-Turkish scandal

Artsakh people's security not subject to compromise. Zohrab Mnatsakanyan

PM's wife made a post on FB page inviting Aliyeva to Artsakh and insisting her invitation is serious

The dream of listening to Mugham will remain unfulfilled. Anna Hakobyan invites Mehriban. . .

€ 23 million for consulting and € 10 million for the private sector

Indian media: Gangster named Budda deported from Armenia

AI powered websites just in few minutes? - Now it’s reality.

Pashinyan Explains to Azerbaijani Journalist Why He Said "Artsakh is Armenia and End"

Two Armenian Catholic priests shot dead by terrorists in Syria

Azerbaijan Man Arrested For Listening To Armenian Music

House overwhelmingly approves resolution recognizing Armenian genocide

This is a vote I've been waiting for for 19 years. Adam Schiff was touched during the talk

Ararat Mirzoyan's speech at the PACE European Conference of Speakers of Parliaments

Speech by Anna Hakobyan at the "Education for All" conference

Tigran Avinyan: the campaign against Amulsar was organized and financed

Aurora Prize Laureates had lunch with children of Orran and UWC Dilijan students

Aurora has become our Nobel Peace Prize. Nikol Pashinyan

Yerevan is older than Rome: Armenian pilot tells passengers of airplane flying to Italy

Armenian lavash on CNN’s list of World’s best breads

Irish Ryanair announces flights from Armenia from 2020

President Sargsyan received the participants of the AGBU "The Stone" program

10 million trees will be planted in Armenia on the 10/10 of 2020. Nikol Pashinyan

Speech by Ararat Mirzoyan at the 130th Assembly of the Inter-Parliamentary Union

Yerevan included in Booking.com’s Top 10 Trending Destinations for 2020

Cher reminds of Armenian Genocide amid Turkey’s Syria assault

Kim Kardashian Baptized in Armenia's Etchmiadzin: Christian Name Heghine

Kim and Kourtney Kardashian visit Armenian President Armen Sarkissian for dinner at the palace․DailyMail

Dudelange vs Qarabag suspended after drone carrying Nagorno-Karabakh flag flies over pitch

Pashinyan meets Putin

Armenian, Singapore PMs discuss broad range of issues on bilateral relations

Nikol Pashinyan's speech at the 74th session of the UN General Assembly

Armenia’s PM Nikol Pashinyan attends reception hosted by Donald Trump

Netanyahu reminds Erdogan of awful massacre of the Armenian people

Film on Armenia’s Velvet Revolution takes runner-up award at Toronto Festival

Mkhitaryan's debut goal at Roma

Top 5 of Project LA songs by views on Youtube channel during the last 30 days

Kim Kardashian West to Visit Armenia and Participate in WCIT 2019

PM’s wife in ‘I Am Not Alone’ world premiere at Toronto Film Festival

European Court of Human Rights Penalizes Both Armenia and Azerbaijan

By Harut Sassounian

Publisher, The California Courier


On December 12, 2017, the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) issued two rulings covering similar lawsuits: one against Armenia and the other against Azerbaijan. Not surprisingly, the Azeri press deceptively reported only the ruling against Armenia, hiding from its readers the fact that a similar judgement was issued against Azerbaijan.

Minas Sargsyan, a refugee from the village of Gulistan in the Shahumyan region of formerly Soviet Azerbaijan, just North of Nagorno-Karabagh (Artsakh), filed a lawsuit against Azerbaijan in the European Court of Human Rights on August 11, 2006. During the Artsakh conflict in 1992, Mr. Sargsyan and his family were forced to flee their home and orchard. Mr. Sargsyan passed away in 2009 in Yerevan. His widow, his son and two daughters continued the lawsuit. When their mother died in 2014, the son and one of the daughters pursued the proceedings. The Sargsyan family demanded compensation for their property losses.

The ECHR referred the case to its Grand Chamber on March 11, 2010. Rejecting various objections from the government of Azerbaijan, the Grand Chamber ruled on June 16, 2015, that the Sargsyan family was entitled to compensation for their property losses. However, no amount was decided until Dec. 12, 2017, when the Grand Chamber ruled that the Sargsyans should be paid by Azerbaijan 5,000 euros to compensate for their property in Gulistan and 30,000 euros for legal costs and expenses.

The Court emphasized that the two conflicting Republics, Armenia and Azerbaijan, were asked by the Court’s Grand Chamber in its 2015 ruling to submit their observations and notify the Court if they had reached any mutual agreement on the Artsakh conflict. Not having reached a political settlement, the two Republics were considered responsible for the property losses of refugees on both sides. The Court stated that Armenia and Azerbaijan prior to their accession to the Council of Europe in 2002, had committed themselves to the peaceful settlement of the Nagorno-Karabagh conflict. Because they had failed to come to a resolution of the conflict, the Court was obliged to assess a monetary compensation for the property losses of the refugees.

The Grand Chamber of the ECHR was composed of 17 judges from various European countries, including judges from Armenia (Armen Harutyunyan), and Azerbaijan (Latif Huseynov). Interestingly, the Azeri judge added a note at the end of the ruling, stating that while he disagreed with the ruling made before he joined the Grand Chamber, he had no choice but to support its decision of allocating compensation. It is clear that the Azeri judge was trying to protect himself from accusations by Azerbaijan that he had ruled in favor of paying compensation to an Armenian family.

In a parallel case, six Kurds who are Azeri citizens filed a joint complaint to the ECHR on April 6, 2005, under the heading: Chiragov and Others vs. Armenia. They complained that because the Armenian forces had taken over the Lachin corridor, they were forced to flee their homes which used to be a part of Soviet Azerbaijan during the Artsakh conflict in 1992.

Similar to the Sargsyan vs. Azerbaijan case, ECHR’s Grand Chamber ruled on June 16, 2015, that Armenia was responsible for the losses of the properties of the six Azeri citizens. They had asked for millions of Euros in compensation. On Dec. 12, 2017, the Grand Chamber ruled that the Armenian Government had to pay 5,000 euros to each of the six Azeri citizens and a total of 28,642 British Pounds for legal costs and expenses. Once again, both Armenian and Azeri judges were part of the 17 judges that formed the Grand Chamber of ECHR. They both voted in favor of the ruling.

The real issue for the ECHR is what to do with the hundreds of thousands of Armenian and Azeri refugees who had also fled their homes during the Artsakh conflict. Will each refugee receive 5,000 euros as compensation and 30,000 euros for legal costs and expenses? The Grand Chamber stated in its ruling that “more than one thousand individual applications lodged by persons who were displaced during the conflict are pending before the Court, slightly more than half of them being directed against Armenia and the remainder against Azerbaijan. The applicants in these cases represent just a small portion of the persons, estimated to exceed one million, who had to flee during the conflict and have since been unable to return to their properties and homes or to receive any compensation for the loss of their enjoyment.”

The only solution is that when someday the Artsakh conflict is resolved, the settlement will include a solution to the situation of the large number of Armenian and Azerbaijani refugees!

Կայքում տեղ գտած մտքերն ու տեսակետները հեղինակի սեփականությունն են և կարող են չհամընկնել Asekose.am-ի խմբագրության տեսակետների հետ: Նյութերի ներքո` վիրավորական ցանկացած արտահայտություն կհեռացվի կայքից:
Politics more